So, you’ve been invited to join a board—congratulations! However, before putting on your best power suit and envisioning yourself as a corporate mastermind, let’s pump the brakes. Board membership is a serious commitment, and diving in without proper due diligence could turn your dream role into a governance nightmare.

To help you make the right decision, here’s a guide on what to evaluate before saying yes, complete with the must-have documents you should review before signing on the dotted line.

Are You Joining for the Right Reasons?

Before diving in, ask yourself why you want to join this board? Board service should be more than just a resume booster or a networking opportunity. There should be a sincere interest in the organization’s mission and a commitment to meaningful contribution.

Good Reasons to Join a Board:

• Community Involvement: You’re passionate about making an impact and giving back.
• Alignment of Vision: The organization’s mission aligns with your values.
• Professional Growth: You want to gain experience and expand your expertise.
• Personal Growth: You want to challenge yourself, learn new skills, and collaborate with diverse professionals.
• Strategic Contribution: You bring valuable knowledge and skills that benefit the organization.

Serving on a board can be gratifying and impactful if your motivations are sincere. However, if your primary focus is power, status, or personal gain, it might not be the right fit for you and could hinder the organization’s success and effectiveness.

Understanding the Organization’s Mission and Values

First, do you actually believe in what this organization stands for? If the mission doesn’t ignite at least a little excitement, sitting through lengthy meetings and making tough calls will feel like an uphill battle.

Key Questions to Ask:

• What is the organization’s mission statement, and how is it reflected in daily operations?
• How does the organization measure success in achieving its mission?
• Have there been any recent changes or challenges related to its mission or values?

Documents to Request:

• Mission statement and strategic plan (if they don’t have one, that’s a red flag!).
• Annual reports and impact assessments to see if they walk the talk.
• Recent communications with stakeholders to understand public perception.

Assessing the Board’s Dynamics and Culture

Would you agree to join a band without knowing if the members get along? Probably not. The same goes for a board. Some boards are high-functioning and collaborative, while others are dysfunctional battlegrounds of egos and hidden agendas.

Key Questions to Ask:

• How are board meetings conducted, and what is the decision-making process?
• Is there a culture of open communication and respectful debate, or is it more of a rubber-stamp situation?
• How does the board handle conflicts of interest and ethical dilemmas?

Documents to Request:

• Board meeting minutes (get a feel for how discussions and decisions happen).
• Board member bios and a skills matrix (to see if expertise is well-rounded or lopsided).
• Code of conduct and conflict of interest policies (because ethics matter!).

Evaluating Time Commitment and Responsibilities

Serving on a board isn’t just about showing up for a couple of meetings and nodding sagely. It often means committee workshops, research, document review, fundraising obligations, and special projects that take up time you might not have.

Key Questions to Ask:

• What is the expected time commitment for meetings, committees, and other responsibilities?
• Are there any significant initiatives or special projects coming up that require additional involvement?
• How does the board assess and hold members accountable for their contributions?

Documents to Request:

• Board meeting schedule and committee charters (to see how much of your calendar will be taken over)
• Board member role descriptions and evaluation criteria (so you know what’s expected of you)
• Recent board self-assessments (if available) to gauge how effective the board is

Reviewing Financial, Legal, and Insurance Documents

If the organization is facing cash flow problems, mounting debt, potential lawsuits, or lacks adequate Directors & Officers (D&O) insurance, you need to be aware before stepping in. The last thing you want is to join a board only to find yourself entangled in financial distress or legal liabilities without protection.

Key Questions to Ask:

• What is the organization’s current financial status, and are there any major financial risks?
• Are there any ongoing or potential legal issues the board should be aware of?
• How does the organization ensure compliance with relevant laws and regulations?
• Does the organization have Directors & Officers (D&O) insurance? Insurance coverage that protects the board members from personal liability.

Documents to Request:

• Financial statements and recent audit reports (if the numbers don’t add up, that’s a problem).
• Bylaws and governance documents (to understand how decisions are made and who holds power).
• Legal reports, and risk assessments (to avoid unwelcome surprises).
• D&O insurance policy (to ensure you’re protected from personal liability in case of legal action against the board).

The Bottom Line: Do Your Homework

Joining a board can be an incredible opportunity, but only if it’s the right fit for both the individual and organization. By asking the right questions and reviewing critical documents, you can position yourself to contribute effectively while protecting your reputation and time.

So, before you say yes to joining a board, take a deep dive into the organization, assess whether you’re up for the challenge, and ensure you’re stepping into a role that aligns with your values and expertise. Do your homework now, and future-you will thank you!

_____________________________________________________

Don’t have a business attorney? Get in touch with our team by emailing Info@harbourbusinesslaw.com.

_____________________________________________________

This Blog was written by Founding Attorney, Katelyn Dougherty.

DISCLAIMER: This blog is for educational purposes only and does not offer nor substitute legal advice. This blog does not establish an attorney-client relationship and is not for advertising or solicitation purposes. Any of the content contained herein shall not be used to make any decision without first consulting an attorney. The hiring of an attorney is an important decision not to be based on advertisements or blogs. Harbour Business Law expressly disclaims any and all liability in regard to any actions, or lack thereof, based on any contents of this blog.